Weathering the Storm

“Weathering the storm” can mean surviving all sorts of difficulties—emotional as well as physical. Since last month’s Typhoon Haiyan seized the Philippines and tornadoes blasted through the U.S. Midwest, though, waves of wind and water have been uppermost on my mind. I tracked Haiyan particularly closely as my adult son was in the Philippine capital, Manila, while Haiyan raged through the island nation. Manila (and my son) were spared, but so many people were not… It is difficult to make sense of such tragedies and their aftermath. As a result, today I am writing about four graphic novels that feature monumental storms. These gripping books range from non-fiction to a fictional crime caper, both impelled by Hurricane Katrina, to the myths and tall tales people have created to explain drenching floods and deadly, dust-filled droughts. The Katrina books contain details and language that readers tween and up will absorb, while the other books will resonate with readers of all ages.

AD New OrleansArtist/illustrator Josh Neufeld began A.D.: New Orleans After the Deluge (2009) after serving as a Red Cross volunteer with victims of 2005’s Hurricane Katrina. In his Introduction and Afterword to this non-fiction book, Neufeld provides statistics about the impact of the devastating storm. He explains how he chose to “tell the story from the perspective of a range of real people…” as well as describing “certain key experiences” about “evacuating the city, facing the flooding, being trapped in the Superdome or Convention Center, and losing all your possessions.” Neufeld interviewed and kept in touch with seven adults who had lived through Katrina, vividly recreating their different personalities and experiences before, during, and after the storm. An underemployed Black counselor living with her extended, female family; a White, ‘Yuppie’ husband and wife; an Iranian-born shopkeeper and his Black, working-class buddy; a middle-class Black teenager, son of a pastor; an upper-class, gay White doctor: these are the real people whose lives Neufeld dramatically captures, the “beating hearts and souls of A.D.,” to whom he dedicates this book.

We come to know and care about these people through Neufeld’s sharp, skillful renditions of their words, deeds, and emotions. A.D. opens with a section about “The Storm” itself, zooming in from outer space with boldly-drawn, then finely-detailed views of New Orleans. We see Katrina’s dramatic impact on the cityscape, sometimes in powerful double spread images, before we ever meet its citizens. But how quickly we come to know them! Abbas and Darnell’s initial, cheerful determination that they can ‘wait out’ the storm is captured in their sparkling fist-bump, Darnell saying “Bro, we are all set. It’s gonna be just like ‘Survivor’!” Yet too soon we see in dramatic double spread images how shaken they and others are by Katrina’s incredible devastation. In the center of one dark-grounded double page, Darnell and Abbas are shown in chest-high muddy water, imagining lighter-colored snakes and alligators swirling around them. A few pages on, the real danger of mosquitos to them is suggested by another, atypically humorous double spread, with one page’s tiny “G’night” ironically facing the other’s image of a giant, buzzing mosquito. The next morning, the men are covered in bites.

AD New Orleans interior page

Neufeld uses double spreads more often to convey painful realizations and realities. He depicts from an overhead, distant perspective the horde of homeless victims waiting to shelter in the city’s Convention Center. In close-up, Neufeld later shows the anguished faces of these people, with their escalating, rumor-fueled fears captured in three word balloons widely-separated across the pages: “There ain’t gonna be no buses comin’!” “They gonna open the floodgates and drown us!” “THEY BROUGHT US HERE TO DIE!” The two-tone contrast used throughout A.D. heightens the impact of such scenes. (The reason for shifting from one color combo to another, though, is not clear.) In smaller panels, color contrast also conveys Denise’s silent, bleak anger as her extended family is turned away from its promised shelter. Her articulate bitterness bursts out later, during Katrina’s immediate aftermath, in a word balloon superimposed over a desolated neighborhood, when she remarks, “This isn’t my life. This is the life of someone I wouldn’t even want to shake hands with.” Neufeld then shows us Denise herself, her hand covering a probably tear-filled face, as she goes on to say, “I think a big part of me was swept away in that hurricane.”

A.D.’s concluding section, titled “The Return,” updates readers about its protagonists and New Orleans’ efforts at recovery through 2008. That remains a mixed success. As Denise, now employed successfully full-time notes, “I am home. But it’s not over.” A large panel depicting the FEMA trailers that were supposed to be temporary shelters contains Denise’s final remark: “We’re not all home yet.” That is the last, powerful image in Neufeld’s book. Yet he and his seven protagonists have remained in touch; A.D’s Afterward describes some of their activities through 2010. There are even more recent updates. In blog posts, New Yorker Neufeld describes how—after 2012’s Hurricane Sandy blasted the Northeast—some of the seven contacted him to see how he had weathered that storm. Neufeld himself is active in Hurricane Sandy relief efforts, some focused on book collections, with projects as current as last month

Dark Rain coverAnother graphic work springing from Hurricane Katrina further shows how monumental storms bring out both the best and worst in people. Dark Rain: A New Orleans Story (2010), written by Mat Johnson and drawn by Simon Gane, with Lee Loughbridge providing grey tones and color and Pat Brosseau the lettering, is a well-done fictional crime caper. Its central plot is a bank heist made possible by the chaos Katrina causes. The book’s events include episodes of violence—with dramatically lettered sound effects such as “BANG,” CREEACK,” “BRAKA BRAKA,” and “BOOM”—typical in action-packed comic books. Similarly, its ex-con hero and its villains—a brutal mercenary soldier named Colonel Driggs and a self-satisfied, snobbish bank manager—are familiar types we have met before. (Ex-con Dabny, the book’s hero, has only broken the law once before, to raise money for his young daughter. This former customs inspector gets involved in the heist when an old cellmate asks for a ride.) Yet the fast-paced action, expressive drawing, shifts between wide and close-shot images, and dramatic use of a limited, dark color palette elevate Dark Rain beyond a typical crime comic. It tells its tale so very well. Sophisticated readers may anticipate much of its outcome, including Dabny’s romance with a strong-willed woman he rescues and his reunion with his daughter, but seeing how the story lines develop and how characters cope with Katrina’s dangers and difficulties hold our attention enjoyably.

Nearly half of Dark Rain’s focus is on the hurricane’s impact on its protagonists and the ordinary citizens of New Orleans and neighboring communities. Some of these communities welcome refugees, while others turn them away. Poor, Black citizens of New Orleans, already an underclass in ‘the Big Easy,’ fare worst in the days following the storm. Yet Johnson and Gane also show how some characters defy stereotypes and expectations. Young gang members help the ill and elderly suffering outside the Superdome, even as their gang clothing and rough appearance cause more conventional citizens to fear them. Katrina’s ‘dark rain’ is brightened by the goodness of some people, even while it foils some of the worst aims of Colonel Driggs and his mercenary force, itself ironically named “Dark Rain Security.”

Dark Rain interior page

One character in Dark Rain remarks about a wrecked neighborhood, “It ain’t right.” Dabny replies, “Not a matter of right or wrong. It’s a hurricane. It’s a flood. It’s not a question of right or wrong, it just is.” Yet Dabny’s view of natural disasters—a view many nowadays, including most scientists, share—has not always been the dominant one. Cultures world-wide have created myths or used religion to explain the occurrence of torrential rains and floods. Three of these ancient explanations are highlighted, others more briefly mentioned, in a recent, beautiful graphic collection of myths. The only ugly thing about this book is its awkwardly long title: Some New Kind of Slaughter—or—Lost in the Flood (and How We Found Home Again) Diluvian Myths from Around the World (2007).

Some New Kind of SlaughterIllustrator MP Mann and author A. David Lewis focus on Zizundra, the ark builder in the ancient Sumerian Epic of Gilgamesh; Noah in the Judeo-Christian tradition; and Da Yu, who controlled floods in Chinese legend. Mann and Lewis weave these stories along with their own creation of a modern “eco-warrior,” a scientist racing to save her U.S. coast family from an approaching Force Four hurricane, into a blended quartet of tales. Organized by a timeframe of “Warnings,” “Preparations,” “Deluge,” and then “Aftermath,” these four main flood stories sometimes converge on pages with four, rectangular panels, each panel illustrating a different flood. At other times, the majestic words of an ancient epic or Bible appear inside modern flood panels. Sometimes, images from different time periods appear within the same large panel.

Some New Kind of Slaughter interior page

I particularly enjoyed such a full page spread early in the “Warnings” section. It depicts underwater the bare legs of an ancient prophet alongside the swimming sea turtle of many legends as these foregrounded figures approach the sunken ruins of four different cultures. A full-color palette is used to great effect throughout this book. Older readers will appreciate the overlap and blending of stories here, including the dreams and adventures of the modern, heroic scientist/mother, while younger readers may take more pleasure in the ancient stories, including the brief accounts of Native American, African, and Australasian flood legends.

Storm in the Barn by Matt PhelanReaders of all ages will enjoy author/illustrator Matt Phelan’s The Storm in the Barn (2009), centered about a different kind of disastrous “rain”—ongoing dust storms. These caused “dust pneumonia” and even “dust dementia” during the prolonged 1930s drought that turned parts of the U.S. and Canada into a savagely poor, barren “Dust Bowl.” Phelan’s swirling lines and muted water color tones, along with a multilayered storyline, have earned this book many kudos, including the 2010 Scott O’Dell Award for historical fiction, the American Library Association’s designation as a Notable Children’s Book, and a YALSA accolade as a Great Graphic Novel for Teens.

We quickly come to care about Jack Clark, Phelan’s 11-year-old protagonist, as he copes with bullies, harsh events such as the mass clubbing of rabbits, and the frightening mystery of a looming figure in the barn. Is Jack himself suffering “dust dementia” when he sees this eerily rain-drenched figure—or is this a supernatural creature, one who has been keeping needed rain away from the area? Maybe a friendly shopkeeper’s tall tales about heroic “Jacks” who defeat gigantic Kings of Blizzards and Northeast Winds have led a sick Jack to imagine a terrible “Storm King” who is malevolently holding rain hostage. Or perhaps this really is an encounter with the supernatural, akin to the world-wide myths about floods described in Some Kind of Slaughter. Phelan begins the novel with an epigraph (from a scientific manual, no less) which supports that possible interpretation: “Every theory of the course of events in nature is necessarily based on some process of simplification of the phenomena and is to some extent therefore a fairy tale.” The many wordless panels support both possibilities—a supernatural encounter as well as illness. The varying size of the panels also make readers aware of how time seems to slow down for people awaiting a terrible event and speeds up for those trying to flee it. The Storm in the Barn concludes with Jack Clark’s father acknowledging the way his son has faced down his fear, whatever its cause, and giving Jack the increased responsibility and respect he has earned.

Storm in the Barn interior by Matt Phelan

Just as Japan’s 2011 earthquake and tsunami, combined with the resulting nuclear power plant accident, have inspired some manga about those disasters, I expect that Hurricane Haiyan, the inspiration for this blog post, may feature in future graphic works. As for me, I am anticipating a late December visit from my son. I can only hope that, having avoided Haiyan, he is not delayed by any of the blizzards or ice storms winter brings us here in Minnesota! I would rather weather those storms after his safe, timely arrival. 

Posted in catastrophe, graphic novels, weather | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Challenged and Challenging

How do you face a challenge? Are you quietly scared and nervous? Do you bluster and bull your way through? Do you take a deep breath, find out what is involved, and then act? Or do you avoid doing anything? What do you do when that challenge is posed by a book—or what other people are saying about a book?

Today I am posting about two sets of controversial graphic novels. But first I need to tell you how and why I selected Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis 1 and 2 and Kim Dong Hwa’s Color trilogy as my focus. I want to highlight them because these vivid, masterful works have been challenged by some parent or community groups as inappropriate reading for students. Recent local uproar over a different book, Rainbow Rowell’s award-winning teen novel Eleanor&Park, has brought censorship—including the banning and literal burning of books—front and center in my mind.

Eleanor & ParkUnlike the parents who objected to Rowell’s novel, taking its use of obscenity and profanity wrongheadedly out of context (from my point-of view), I found Rowell’s dialogue fresh and natural, her insights into teens and adults sharp and nuanced. I thought it ironic that while her character Eleanor finds safety with an uncle in St. Paul, author Rowell had been ‘uninvited’ to speak with students in St. Paul’s neighboring Anoka-Hennepin School District. Now, nearly two months later, I am pleased to learn that the St. Paul Library itself has invited Rowell to visit and has selected Eleanor & Park for its community-wide Read Brave Program. By the time this blog entry is online, Rowell will have appeared at the first of these community gatherings.

The brouhaha over Eleanor & Park calls to mind the misgivings some people once had about almost all comic books. In the 1940s and 1950s, acting on the mistaken idea that reading comics led to juvenile delinquency, some U.S. communities even tolerated the public burning of piles of comics.  This bit of U.S. history horrifies me, particularly coming so soon after the end of World War II, when Nazi atrocities first became known world-wide. Hitler had fulfilled the ominous prediction of 19th century author Heinrich Heine, who wrote “Where they burn books, they will ultimately burn people, too.” Public burning of books that Nazis considered decadent or dangerous began in Germany in 1933, and just a few years later the mass extinction of similarly labeled authors, readers, and finally entire populations began. Viewed within this historical context, the censorship or banning of books is the first, dangerous step on a devastatingly slippery slope.

PersepolisYet challenges of individual books—including graphic novels—continue to be made by concerned parents and community groups, occasionally even educators, for a variety of often well-intentioned reasons. And sometimes (from my point-of-view) their objections have some merit, although I would argue that censorship is not the solution to the problems, real or potential, they identify. One case of this is the Spring, 2013 challenges brought in Chicago to Marjane Satrapi’s acclaimed Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood. (Nowadays this memoir is also published together with Persepolis 2: The Story of a Return in one volume titled The Complete Persepolis.)

Satrapi’s memoir of her childhood in Iran, from the ages of six to fourteen, focuses on events after the Islamic Revolution of 1979, when she was nine years old. Islamic law and rules of modesty, including headscarves for all females and figure-concealing clothing for women, were soon enforced—sometimes brutally. Educational and social activities also became restricted. When Marjane and her schoolmates first receive their “veils,” they do not understand how their lives will change. A first-page panel shows the schoolyard games they play with these scarves, bold black-and-white drawings capturing the care-free humor of this active play. Another early panel symbolizes the dislocating impact of the Revolution on Marjane and all Iranians: her figure is split in half, with the short-haired, Western-garbed side shown against a black background displaying white scientific gears and tools. Marjane’s black-veiled, hajib-wearing half stands out against a white background decorated with the typical non-representational swirls of Islamic art. Iran will similarly be ‘torn apart’ by the demands of its new, theocratic government. Persepolis also depicts the impact of the long years of the subsequent Iran-Iraq war on young Marjane, her family, and their acquaintances.

from Persepolis by Marjane Satrapis

Throughout this book and its sequel, which follows Marjane into young adulthood and marriage, Satrapi continues to employ varied, sophisticated visual techniques. Overlapping panels; dramatic, sometimes full-page black backgrounds; and repetition of small images as borders or within entire panels communicate her experiences and opinions clearly and vividly. Ironically, it is Satrapi’s very success as a storyteller that led to the Chicago challenge and limited banning of Persepolis. In a decision eerily reminiscent of Iranian censorship, Chicago school officials first removed Persepolis from one high school and then ordered it removed from all district classrooms and libraries. Its language and images were termed too “graphic,” in the negative senses of that word. After protests by students, teachers, and anti-censorship groups, district officials backtracked on this decision, limiting the ban to 7th grade classrooms.

Officials cited one panel depicting torture of a political prisoner as the reason for keeping Persepolis out of the hands and curriculum of 7th graders. I confess I find their concern a valid one, although I vehemently reject the decision to which it led. Satrapi depicts torture and body dismemberment not just in one panel but on an entire page. I agree with the Chicago Public Schools officials who called these “powerful images of torture,” even though Satrapi herself disagrees. She has responded that her “black-and-white drawing … [is not] extremely horrible” and is not comparable to “photos of torture” or other things 7th graders can see “on cinema and the internet.” I think her response, while true in some ways, does not give her own achievements enough credit. (And, just because Persepolis describes the experiences of a child and young teen, the age of this figure does not, as some anti-censorship groups note, mean that the book is meant to be read by this young audience. That logic would suggest that Persepolis is not worth the while of adult readers!) Instead of removing and banning this book from 7th grade classes, I would have urged a letter be sent to teachers with information about how to discuss the torture and other government actions depicted in Satrapi’s work. Censorship only abets the abuse of power, which still can be seen in Iran today, where too little has changed. A recent graphic novel depicting contemporary government oppression there, including the torture and murder of dissidents, shields its creators with pseudonyms. “Amir” and “Khalil,” the author and artist responsible for Zahra’s Paradise (2011), fear reprisal for their families and themselves if their true identities became known in Iran. This work contains—along with scenes of rape, torture, and public execution—some panels depicting consensual sex. Iran’s banning of all R-rated, critical works such as Zahra’s Paradise, its criminalization of their authors, are all the more reason to avoid censorship here.

Colors by Kim Dong Hwa

It is sex—specifically, nudity, sex education, and sexual explicitness—that in 2011 made Kim Dong Hwa’s Colors trilogy (The Color of Earth, The Color of Water, and The Color of Heaven) the second most frequently challenged book for young readers in the United States. Yet this series has also been acclaimed and its first volume singled out as one of YALSA Top Ten Graphic Novels for Teens and one of Booklist’s Top Ten Graphic Novels for Youth. I heartily echo this praise. Author/illustrator Hwa does a splendid job depicting the lives of a widowed mother and her young daughter in early 1900s rural Korea. Their close, loving relationship as the mother runs a small tavern to support them is depicted in acute, sensitive detail, as is village life in general. The psychological development of daughter Ehwa and her playmates, ages seven to thirteen in The Color of Earth, is also handled deftly. Believable situations lead them from discovering the physical differences between girls and boys, to first menstruation and wet dreams, onward to first innocent “crushes” and the realization that adults experience such emotions, too. In The Color of Water, Hwa includes teen masturbation and adult sexuality—topics which have also proven to be ‘red flags’ to those who wish to censor his work. In The Color of Heaven, Hwa further develops his life cycle approach towards emotional and physical development by depicting 17 year old Ehwa’s wedding night and the sexuality of village elders, whose bodies sometimes fail to ‘rise’ to their desires.

Colors by Kim Dong Hwa

Throughout the trilogy, Hwa uses symbols in words and images to represent sexual feelings and emotions. Randy men are beetles, children becoming adolescents resemble new butterflies, while different emotions and people are associated with individual kinds of flower. These connections, often rooted in Korean folklore, are noted by asterisks in the text, with brief, helpful explanations then given at the bottom of the page. Hwa conveys the joy of Ehwa and her husband Duksum through images of waves, clouds, and bright sunshine, as well as partial glimpses of their nude bodies. Throughout the trilogy, Hwa uses a range of line drawings to show village settings and outdoor scenes in skillful, realistic detail. One’s eye lingers on the page to absorb their intricate, satisfying patterns, textures, and details. Yet at other times Hwa employs some non-realistic visual conventions—such as ‘cat tongues’ on the faces of mischievous kids and ‘stitched’ mouths on the faces of embarrassed characters—typical of both manhwa (Korean comics) and manga (Japanese comics). (Unlike manga, Korean comics are published and read “Western style”—front- to- back and left- to- right.) Hwa also varies panel and image size to great effect, using double-page and one-and-a-half page spreads for dramatic emphasis.

Because both the Colors trilogy and Persepolis challenge readers to think and feel deeply about important topics, simultaneously cultivating and satisfying our visual awareness, I believe these books should be accessible to tweens and teens. The adults in their lives may want to explain or comment on some of the content in these works, but banning them from schools or libraries does a disservice to young readers. And such censorship, as history reveals, sometimes leads to further, dangerous legal rulings.

This month, movie-goers (who may have seen the 2007 film Persepolis, based on both Satrapi memoirs) will have another opportunity to revisit the horrific implications of book banning and burning. The filmed version of Markus Zuzak’s powerful novel about Nazi Germany, The Book Thief, debuts in wide-release. Its central character is a young girl named Liesel who loves books. In May, 1933, she rescues one volume from Munich’s huge pyre of burning books and also attempts, along with some German adults, to shelter Jews from Nazi persecution. Yet Dachau concentration camp, located just 10 miles outside of Munich, continues and grows, feeding the flames of its human holocaust for another twelve years. Not enough people challenged Hitler and his Nazi regime while there was still time to do this.

Posted in graphic novels | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Halloween All Year Long—Manga Style

Kitaro and his fatherPerplexed by that drawing of a shaggy-headed, one-eyed boy, with an eyeball-shaped critter perched on top of his head? You may be amazed to discover that Japanese storyteller Shigeru Mizuki has spun hundreds of tales about this cartoon creation of his—a supernatural hero named “Kitaro.”

KitaroOctober 31 means spooky fun for kids in North America and parts of western Europe. The thrills and chills of Halloween ‘haunted houses,’ eerie hayrides, and ghastly costumes also appeal to many tweens and teens. Now, thanks to a brand-new translation into English, we readers of Japanese manga (comic books and graphic novels, typeset back-to-front) have a special Halloween treat. With Kitaro (2013), we can finally enjoy the popular cartoon character who, for more than fifty years, has brought supernatural adventures year-round to Japanese readers young and old. In Japan, the character of Kitaro is as popular and well-known as Charlie Brown and Garfield are in the United States. Like those characters and their cartoon pals, Kitaro and his associates have also starred in successful TV series, specials, and movies. Kitaro’s creator, Shigeru Mizuki, is as famous in Japan as Charlie Brown’s creator, Charles Shulz, is here in North America. His hometown of Sakaiminato hosts a Mizuki museum and has even erected statues of 133 different supernatural creatures who figure in Kitaro’s adventures as enemies or allies.

Kitaro HalloweenLike Kitaro himself, these creatures are “yokai”—a Japanese word that includes the wide range of supernatural creatures described in Japanese folktales first told hundreds of years ago. Often shape shifters, these spirits, ghosts, and demons may do good or evil. One part of Shigeru Mizuki’s achievements is his compilation of the many different local stories about yokai told all across Japan, bringing these to life through his drawn tales. When we meet these supernatural beings alongside Kitaro, the yokai character developed by Mizuki, the fun begins! Kitaro only (mostly) looks like an ordinary boy; this kind-hearted, brave figure is really the child of two ghosts, born in a graveyard, whose dead father has resurrected himself into an eye-ball sized helper who now lives inside Kitaro’s empty eyesocket! After popping up and out to aid Kitaro with tough problems, this creature likes to relax in a teacup bath. That kind of “yucky” detail is sure to entertain young readers, especially ones who appreciate the fake goo, gore, and grim elements of Halloween.

Kitaro is himself a shape shifter. In “The Cat Master,” one of the 15 stories in this 400 page collection, Kitaro slyly changes himself into a ball of yarn to defeat a human-sized, supernaturally-strong cat. The evil yokai Neko Senin has used this form to attack villagers. After defeating Neko Senin, Kitaro as usual refuses any reward for his help. He wanders away, serenaded by the approving chorus of insects whose chirping noises—“Ge ge ge”—are a standard part of these tales and frequently appear in the titles of some Japanese collections and Kitaro TV shows. This detail—along with others about Japanese locations, customs, and history—is asterisked within the story and explained at the end of the anthology in brief notes. As each new yokai is introduced in the collection, an asterisk also refers readers to a helpful, illustrated guide to yokai located right after these notes.

In other stories, readers learn that Kitaro has an antenna-like hair that sticks straight up to help him locate spirits. He also keeps a pet snake in his stomach—a useful ally to wrap around and trap pesky villains! In one story, Kitaro tackles some supernatural villains that need no introduction to western readers: Frankenstein’s monster and Dracula. But one of my personal favorites here harkens back to monstrous Japanese creatures that may be almost as well-known by western readers—skyscraper-sized Godzilla and other huge figures who in 1950s and 1960s movies rose out of the ocean to terrorize Tokyo and other major cities. In “Creature from the Deep,” an evil scientist transforms unsuspecting Kitaro into one of these rampaging creatures! We see crowds of terrified people fleeing from him. With his last bit of self-awareness, Kitaro stops his destructive rampage and deliberately sinks down into radioactive waters that spell his doom. Only the efforts of his yokai father and another friendly yokai save noble Kitaro and help him catch the evil scientist.

In “Creature from the Deep” and other stories, Mizuki makes effective use of dark silhouettes to convey the danger posed by certain creatures and locations. Mizuki’s drawing of cityscapes and landscapes in realistic detail—a contrast to the less realistic, cartoon-like appearance of Kitaro and other figures—is typical not only of Mizuki but of his generation of post-World War II Japanese graphic artists. These detailed panels are visually rich and satisfying, as well as effectively paced. Even though Mizuki seldom draws outside of panel frames and only infrequently uses overlapping or irregularly-shaped panels, their rare appearance at dramatic high points adds further “punch” at these appropriate moments. Similarly, Mizuki’s infrequent use of full page or double page images heightens their impact on the reader.

NonNonBaReaders who enjoy Kitaro may take further delight in Mizuki’s autobiographical NonNonBa (2012), a graphic novel depicting his boyhood in 1920s and 1930s Japan. NonNonBa is the nickname of the elderly neighbor who first taught young Shigeru about the spirits called called yokai. She also helped him cope with the harsh realities of disease and poverty in that place and time. Along with sadness and loss, this quiet novel of daily life contains moments of boyish fun and mayhem, parental wisdom and foolishness, and an awareness of mystical beliefs and connections that has remained important to Mizuki throughout his long life. (He is now a remarkable 92 years old!) NonNonBa, which contains helpful end notes similar to Kitaro’s, won an Angouleme award, an honor conferred by European graphic artists. Before these recent English translations, Mizuki’s books had been translated into French and Italian.

Onwards Towards Our Honorable DeathsHaving savored both Kitaro and NonNonBa, I now look forward to reading Shigeru Mizuki’s semi-autobiographical Onward Towards Our Noble Deaths (2011; published in Japan in 1973), an account of being a soldier in Papua New Guinea during World War II. Mizuki lost his left arm during that conflict. This loss, along with other wartime experiences, has led him to criticize war in interviews as well as his graphic works. The ironically-titled Onward Toward Our Noble Deaths won an Eisner Award after its English publication. This work as well as another recent Mizuki translation into English is far removed from the light-hearted, fake violence and thrilling chills of Halloween and the happy endings of Kitaro tales.

Showa: 1926-1937 A History of JapanMizuki’s Showa: 1926 – 1939: A History of Japan (2013) is the first volume of two covering the reign of Japan’s Emperor Hirohito, which lasted until 1989. Showa—looking at the situations and events, often brutal themselves, that led up to the official start of World War II—will be published on October 22, 2013. Its Canadian publisher, Drawn & Quarterly Press has announced that Showa’s narrator is one of Mizuki’s often friendly yokai. I wonder if and how Mizuki has used this character to make complex history accessible to readers of all ages.

Posted in graphic novels, manga | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Faces of Labor: Family Albums, Library Shelves

This Labor Day I am thinking of my mother . . . .

In a 1940s photograph, her womanly face glows with confidence. She sits at a dinner table with a handful of men, their suits and ties matching her festive dress and upswept hair. As a child, I already knew that Mom had been a “Rosie the Riveter,” working on World War II battleships in the Brooklyn Navy Yard. But how did this photograph fit into her past? Only its chance discovery revealed that my mother had also been a union leader then, the shop steward for many other machinists. The snapshot had been taken at a yearly union banquet. My child’s curiosity satisfied, I could not imagine how decades later I would circle back to this photograph and this time in my mother’s life. It would take that long for me to appreciate how that union experience was the pinnacle of Mom’s work life—the only opportunity she ever had to use fully talents curtailed by the Depression and post-war economy. The Depression had forced her to drop out of high school; after World War II, most “Rosies,” including my mother, were replaced by male workers.

Kings in DisguiseSo, in tribute to my mother and others who weathered the Depression, finding some fellowship and reward in labor unions, I am blogging this month about two phenomenally powerful graphic novels set in 1930s America. The youthful protagonist in Kings in Disguise (1988; 2006) and its brand-new sequel, On the Ropes (2013), written by James Vance and illustrated by Dan E. Burr, is about the same age my mother was during the years they cover—1932 to 1937. Fictional Fred Bloch also has his education cut short by the Depression and his life affected by union activities. Fortunately, though, my mother never experienced the violent, real-life strikes and union-busting activities that are the factual basis for these historical novels. These events and similar ones are explained further in the nonfiction graphic works about labor leaders and history that I briefly describe at the end of this entry. While Vance and Burr’s novels are best appreciated by older readers (tween and up), three of the nonfiction works are suited to younger readers too.

Californian Fred Bloch is nearly 13, anticipating his bar mitzvah, when his jobless, desperate father abandons Fred and his older brother to search for work. In 1932, that difficult search leads Mr. Bloch to Detroit, where he writes that he has gotten a job in “the car factory.” That is Fred’s destination when he flees his home town to avoid being placed in an orphanage. Kings in Disguise follows Fred’s life over the next year and a half, as the movie and book-loving boy discovers that what he had “once thought of as ‘adventure’ . . . . was what was inflicted upon those who couldn’t run and hide.”

Kings in Disguise exampleFor most of this time, Fred rides the rails as a homeless hobo, seeing both the worst and best in human nature. He is befriended by older, tubercular Sam, who jokingly makes light of their straits by calling himself “the King of Spain” and Fred “the King of France.” Sam selflessly protects Fred from sexual predators, but he cannot protect him from the nightmares Fred has about those predators, or railroad guards who bludgeon hobos, or townspeople who destroy the ragtag, packing crate communities sometimes built by otherwise homeless wanderers. Burr’s black-and-white illustrations wonderfully communicate the hallucinatory, overwhelming nature of these nightmares, with images shown from different, at times distorted angles; faces sometimes drawn as gloating, cartoonish masks; and styles that vary from sharp, bold lines to swirling, lighter ones. Swathes of darkness, cross-hatched backgrounds, and frameless panels that alternate with or bleed into framed ones are also used to great effect. In these scenes and elsewhere, Burr’s visual narrative is so strong that entire pages are frequently wordless, yet they eloquently communicate both action-packed scenes and thought-filled revelations. Vance’s dialogue winding through other pages keeps readers in the moment with slang and expressions suited to the era—as Sam admiringly tells Fred at one point, “Boy, you said a mouthful!” Yet what he experiences in Detroit and nearby Dearborn, Michigan leaves even Fred speechless.

Befriended by union organizers, Fred takes part in the real-life Ford Hunger Strike, sometimes also called the Ford Massacre. When three thousand laid-off auto plant workers, carrying picket signs that declared “We Want Bread, not Crumbs,” in March, 1932 refused to leave Ford factory grounds, armed guards and Detroit police shot into the crowd. Five were killed and at least 60 were injured, many as they attempted to flee. Vance and Burr dramatically show the impact of this experience on Fred in a remarkable double-page spread. The left-hand page contains only the large hobo sign or shorthand for “Danger.” The right-hand page has four top panels in which Fred reads a Bible while thinking back to the recent massacre. The bottom-two thirds of the page shows bodies littering that scene, as police look on, arresting or questioning some wounded strikers while others hobble away. In ironic counterpoint to this devastation are the Biblical, life-giving words “And the spirit of God moved the face of the waters.”

Young Fred learns of the dangers of union-organizing, and he also sees how racism and anti-Semitism are the unquestioned norms of many white working-class lives. After Sam draws one bigot aside for a remark about Jews, the man apologizes to Fred, saying he did not know he was “one of those.” Yet Fred feels he has learned something even more important: “that by banding together [workers] could avoid destruction entirely, they could even fight back.” As the older Fred narrating this work says, “I put my childhood behind me and resumed my leftward journey.” (That direction refers to the Socialist and Communist Parties, frequently involved then in union-organizing.) The Eisner and Harvey Award winning Kings in Disguise concludes with one of young Fred’s dreams. He peers sadly into a coffin containing, one assumes from its shipping address, the body of his father, and then moves on, literally walking out of a lamppost’s light into the dark night. While Fred, now barely 14 years old, says I am “on my own” he also feels “accompanied by multitudes” seeking their fair share of the American dream.

On the RopesOn the Ropes (2013) begins in 1937, with 17 to 18 year old Fred at work in the travelling WPA Circus. (This real-life organization was one of the more unusual groups sponsored by President Roosevelt’s Works Progress Administration to employ performers and artists.) Fred is the assistant to Gordon, the circus’s featured “Escape Artist,” who each performance defies death while hanging from a noose knotted around his neck. Hard-drinking, cynical Gordon—a disillusioned WW I veteran—early in the novel tells his impoverished, entertainment-hungry audience that “We’re all scared these days, my friends . . . on the ropes, like a nation of punch-drunk fighters.” This bleak view echoes the novel’s narrator, an older Fred who warns us right away that his adventure-filled tale is a grim one. As we see a young boy smiling up at the show and then see assistant Fred offstage, this narrator reflects that “So few understand that even though most of us escaped with our lives—that doesn’t mean that any of us survived.”

On the Ropes exampleIn flashbacks to the years between 1933 and 1937, Vance and Burr show us the physical as well as emotional costs Fred has paid for his life on the rails. Burr’s spot-on illustrations of period clothing, hairstyles, and settings transform into a surreal, photographic “negative” and then fade to black as Fred is maimed while trying to hop a ride . . . and briefly escapes into unconsciousness. Fred re-finds purpose for his life by becoming a travelling mail ‘drop’ for union activists; in the circus, he even finds his first, true love with manager’s assistant Eileen, herself not yet twenty. A journalist writing about the circus encourages Fred to rework his own writing into a book. Yet harsh realities—part of real labor history—crash into these dreams. Visiting that journalist, Fred witnesses the Republic Steel Strike, also known as the Memorial Day Massacre. In May 1937, Chicago police shot into and then beat a crowd of 1500 people outside the gates of the Republic Steel Factory. The police killed and injured not only laid-off workers but wives and children who had accompanied them on that holiday. While Fred is away from the circus, two thugs hired as union-busters—another labor history fact—come in search of him. Their brutal activities have been a subplot throughout the novel. Sexual violence, plus one thug’s past relationship with Gordon, tinges their actions. Not finding Fred, the union-busters ‘question’ Eileen. While this crime is not shown, Gordon and returning Fred’s final encounter with these murderers is depicted in a crescendo of violence. Close-ups, shifting points-of-view, and dramatic swathes of inky black and dark grey, along with pages of fast-paced, wordless action, sweep readers along at a breathless pace. Is what happens then justice, a “vigilante bloodbath,” or both? Regardless of the answer, what follows—in two nearly wordless pages in which Fred reaches towards a dying Gordon—is a remarkably wrenching visual coda.

As older Fred narrates the novel’s final panels, showing his younger self leaving the circus, he notes that it would take “years to understand” these events and figure out how “not to waste my life.” Older Fred remarks, “I’m still trying to take that step.” Author Vance has written that there is a chance he and Burr will create another novel about Fred Bloch. Vance already knows what happens next to Fred! Yet On the Ropes is satisfyingly complete as is—and so well done that I fully expect it to be become another award-winner for its creators.

Wobblies!For more about labor history, leaders, and the conflicts between and within unions, older readers can turn to the non-fiction anthology Wobblies! A Graphic History of the Industrial Workers of the World (2005). Its editors Paul Buhle and Nicole Schulman provide clearly-written comments explaining and linking the entries they have chosen, created by 35 graphic authors and illustrators. These pieces display a wide range of graphic techniques and storytelling, many extremely effective, and cover less well-known events and figures as well as prominent ones. This is fascinating, sometimes disturbing reading.

Cesar ChavezYounger readers interested in labor history and leaders will benefit from these non-fiction graphic works: Cesar Chavez: Fighting for Farmworkers (2006); Mother Jones: Labor Leader (2007); and The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire (2006). The fast-paced storytelling of these books, part of Capstone Press’s Graphic Library series, and their distinction between original quotations (shown against a yellow background) and “made-up” dialogue are pluses that respect the abilities of all readers, regardless of age. Second language learners will also find these books worthwhile.

Masks of AnarchyFinally—since I began this entry with “Who knew?” bit of family labor history—I think it appropriate that I end it with a “Who knew?” item of global labor history. I discovered this in a book with a mouthful of a title—Masks of Anarchy: The History of a Radical Poem, from Percy Shelley to the Triangle Factory Fire (2013), written by Michael Demson and illustrated by Summer McClinton. This non-fiction graphic work focuses on the impact one poem written by British Shelley had nearly a century later on the life and work of American labor organizer Pauline Newman. His inspirational words to suffering workers—“Ye are many, they are few.”—became her lifelong motto. I did not know that!

Chapters there alternate between Shelley’s life and Newman’s, showing us how he came to write “Masks of Anarchy” and how she as a child immigrated to America. Later, we see the rest of Shelley’s life unfold (supposedly from his second wife’s viewpoint) and see Newman (supposedly writing about herself) working first as a child laborer and then as a union organizer. Newman did piecework at the infamous Triangle Shirtwaist Factory long before she rallied workers after the terrible, death-dealing fire there. McClinton’s high angle drawings of the British Peterloo labor massacre, which galvanized Shelley, along with a montage of frame-breaking, overlapping images of the Triangle fire deaths, are particularly moving.

Readers tween and up will appreciate this book, though some may have questions about Shelley’s own lack of care and respect for women and servants. It seems clear here (as it does elsewhere) that this poet “talked the talk but did not walk the walk” in these areas, however inspirational his writing. The book’s Foreword by historian Paul Buhle, itself a labor of love and appreciation, is geared towards other historians rather than casual readers. Buhle’s careful analysis need not be read first or at all for readers to understand and appreciate this hybrid graphic novel, effectively combining non-fiction with two “fictionalized” autobiographies. I know my own mother, whose first job was on the assembly line of a Manhattan candy factory, would have relished learning about Pauline Newman.

Posted in graphic novels, labor | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

War-Torn Pages Ripped from History

World War II is making headlines again. A 94-year-old man, living just a few miles from me here in Minnesota, has been revealed as a probable war criminal. Michael Karkoc was an officer in two Nazi-led Ukrainian military units. He was on the scene of, and perhaps directly responsible for, massacres of civilians as well as the deaths of anti-Nazi guerrilla fighters. Had Karkoc’s connection with these units been known, he would not have been permitted to immigrate to the United States in 1949. Yet one of these groups called itself the “Ukrainian Self Defense Legion,” and Karkoc has been proudly active in Ukrainian-American organizations since his arrival. This disconnect between “defense” and brutal offense, between civic pride and shame, is mind-boggling. When Karkoc —asked about his wartime work for the Nazis—replied, “I don’t think I can explain,” I think he was speaking more truth than he knew.

Some graphic literature shows how much talent it takes to analyze and describe the many layers of wartime experience, particularly inside a conquered country. A recent trilogy of graphic novels about World War II France succeeds in powerfully communicating this experience. Similarly, a brand-new duology stuns us with its look at an earlier conflict inside war-torn China. These novels are brilliant successes because—even as they provide answers about specific wartime experiences—they raise further questions in our minds about human nature, beliefs, and values. Get ready to ask yourself, “What would I have done?” as you read about these past struggles. Count yourself lucky if you do not have to ask the question some people worldwide face every day, in ongoing and emerging conflicts: “What will I do?”

Resistance TrilogyOne possible answer is “resist the enemy.” French life after defeat by Nazi Germany is the focus of the Resistance trilogy (2010; 2011; 2012), written by Carla Jablonski, with art by Leland Purvis and color by Hilary Sycamore. The wrap-around covers of its volumes, viewed in sequence, show central character Paul’s growing towards adulthood as, between 1942 and 1945, he defies the Nazi regime. Resistance: Book 1, beginning three years into France’s occupation, depicts 13 year old Paul aiming a slingshot at a Nazi soldier. On the cover of Defiance: Resistance Book 2, 14 year old Paul has moved on to acts of sabotage, puncturing the tire of a car guarded by an armed Vichy policeman. The cover of Victory: Resistance Book 3, shows 15 to 16 year old Paul committing more physically-dangerous sabotage, destroying an overhead telephone line with a wire cutter. Yet braving physical danger is only one of the challenges facing Paul, his younger and older sisters Marie and Sophie, and his Jewish friend Henri.

What to think and whom to trust are constant worries, as Paul Tessier’s family copes with the absence of their father, a prisoner of war still being held by the Germans, and the presence of occupying German soldiers in their country town. When the Nazis begin to round up Jews, these questions become life-and-death issues not only for Henri but for Paul and Marie, who decide to hide him. Can they trust their aunt who, like some other French people, was anti-Semitic long before the Nazis arrived? Has Sophie grown too close to the German soldier she has been dating, supposedly to find out Nazi plans? Will their schoolmate, whose father is a Vichy police officer cooperating with the Nazis, knowingly or unknowingly betray them? Are they in danger even from members of the French Resistance, who in Book I fear that Marie’s childish outbursts will reveal important secrets?

The series’ creators make great storytelling use of Paul’s own artwork. His charcoal drawings, shown as sepia-toned sketchbook pages, set scenes and speak volumes. At one moment of great tension in Book I, a single page displays not only inserted, small panels with full-color close-ups of Paul and Marie’s frightened faces, but mid-distance shots of villagers going about their daily routines while looking suspiciously at each other. A mid-page panel— outlined as a ripped-out page from Paul’s sketch book—is filled with the charcoal-drawn faces of his angry, distrustful classmates. This sketched image unites the page, where no words are used or needed to communicate Paul and Marie’s fearful suspense. At other points in the trilogy, sketchbook images also represent some of Paul’s on-the-spot ideas and reactions, as he thinks in visual terms.

Other effective visual elements in this series include using the same shade of blue to “color-code” flashbacks to Nazi violence. Speech balloons which overlap panels unite them with added urgency, as does varying the size and arrangement of panels on pages. The perspective from which we see scenes also shifts effectively, with some overhead views permitting readers to see action along an entire street or within an entire room. These elements support crisp dialogue that in subtle as well as plain-spoken ways communicates the impact of war in occupied France. At the start of Book 1, Madame Tessier still thinks that she can hold onto parts of her old life. She tells Paul to “Put on shoes. We’re not refugees.” Later in this volume, 10 year-old Marie naively echoes her mother’s reassuring phrase. Yet by the end of Book 1, after the Tessier siblings have gotten Henri safely to Paris, they have lost this false sense of safe distance from the worst wartime events. In that volume’s final, double page spread, they are riding a train, from which they see scenes of Nazi occupation. These bleak, wordless panels conclude with two stark word balloons. A serious Marie notes that, “This really isn’t over, is it?” Paul, equally solemn, replies in a balloon dropped down into his sketchbook image of their train, “I think this is just the beginning.” Author Carla Jablonski has effectively summed up and set the stage for the next parts of the trilogy.

ResistanceThese second and third books depict Marie’s growing disillusionment with the Vichy government as well as further acts of sabotage, rescues of downed Allied pilots, and confrontations with Nazi troops. There is action aplenty for readers here! All the while, though, the Tessier family continues to deal with the brother-and-sister, parent-and-child, and schoolmate, sweetheart, and neighbor interactions that, in peacetime, would have been the focus of their lives. These relationships add luster to the trilogy’s concluding pages, as Paul watches the sparkling lights of Paris, now liberated from the Nazis. We have come to know Paul and his community, to understand why in an Author’s Note Jablonski distinguishes written history, with its “definite winners and losers, friends and enemies, loyalities and betrayals” from “History as lived [which] is anything but clear … filled with missteps, confusion, mistakes, and choices .” Jablonski’s crisp, thorough introductions to each book and concluding Author’s Notes help readers understand the complex situations and choices confronting people living in war-torn, occupied countries—situations that bring out the worst as well as the best in some of us. The information specific to WW II France is immensely useful here, particularly for teen or tween readers who may be less familiar with its central figures and events.

Boxers and SaintsI wish author/illustrator Gene Luen Yang had included comparable introductions or notes for his stunning new graphic duology, Boxers & Saints (2013). In these volumes colored by Lark Pien, Yang—creator of the award-winning American Born Chinese (2006)—does an unforgettably good job of depicting teenagers who choose warfare, unlike Jablonski’s characters, whose resistance is a reaction to war imposed upon them. Boxers & Saints is set in 1900 China, a period in which some Chinese revolted against foreign influence, especially Christian missionaries, in their country. These Chinese “Boxers” fought for their own ways and religion and considered Chinese converts to Christianity, Yang’s “Saints,” to be their enemies, too. I think Yang’s powerful narrative and compelling images will keep readers engrossed in the story, but “at-hand” background information about this distant time and place and about traditional Chinese culture would have been useful. For instance, it is just assumed that the reader knows about women’s inferior position in that culture and our association with supposedly weakening “yin” energy as opposed to male “yang.” So is some knowledge about acupuncture, the history of the Chinese empire of the time, and Chinese religion and literature. Yet the internet and libraries are available and Yang does provide a “Further Reading” list. I believe intrigued readers both young and old will find any information they need, wanting to understand more about Yang’s compelling characters and the disturbing, sometimes mystifying events in their lives.

The covers of these volumes reflect the unusual storytelling choice Yang has made. Proclaiming that “Every war has two faces,” these books when placed side-by-side line up half-head shots of the main characters, Bao and Vibiana. They unite to form one powerful image of youthful distress and determination. Boxers tells events from Bao’s viewpoint, both before and after the teenage boy joins this revolutionary movement. Saints covers the same events from Vibiana’s viewpoint, beginning even earlier with her hard life at age 8, before she converts to Christianity and becomes one of the teenaged “secondary devils” the Boxers attack. Ironically, the two just miss bumping into each other once and are connected by several incidents well-before their eventual, fateful meeting. Early in the book, younger Bao thinks the angry-faced girl he glimpses is fascinating, and briefly daydreams about marrying her. Real life events stop such daydreaming. Readers may well think that this pair of strong-willed individuals is a fated couple, kept apart by circumstances outside their power as well as by choices they make.

Boxers

A desire to belong and be respected, a way to escape a terrible home life, and a community that offers both along with the fellowship of shared beliefs and values: these are all reasons sometimes given nowadays for teens joining gangs. They are also a large part of what motivates Bao and Vibiana to join their opposing religious camps. Both young people experience visions related to their religious beliefs. Bao sees and hears traditional Chinese gods, dressed as he has seen these figures portrayed on the stage of travelling opera companies. He believes these gods enter and protect Boxers as they fight for justice. Vibiana sees and hears a glowing Joan of Arc, both before and after this 15th century French girl becomes the maiden warrior canonized in 1920 as St. Joan. These brightly-colored visions, eye-catching against the more muted tones of daily life in the books, may be interpreted in several ways.

Saints

The visions of Bao and Vibiana may be authentic religious experiences, or they may merely be the imaginings of excited, eager-to-be-special young people. No one else seems to see these visions, and in fact they do not by themselves physically protect anyone. As his fellow Boxers are slain, Bao sees their god-like figures departing from the corpses. Yet Yang’s images continue to show great respect for traditional Chinese beliefs even as he goes on in Saints to detail Christianity. This is evident in one stunning, full-page image close to the end of Saints, where Vibiana is praying to Jesus Christ for guidance. Her vision of him resembles the way Guan Yin, the Chinese goddess of compassion, is often shown: surrounded by an array of 1,000 compassionate hands, each displaying an eye of compassion. The crucifixion wounds of this golden, glowing Christ have also been transformed into compassionate eyes. Yang does not scoff at the power or authenticity of religious belief. In fact, in an interview he has noted that 87 Chinese Christians slain during the Boxer Rebellion were canonized—declared “saints”—by the Catholic Church in 2000. Fictional Vibiana is one of these martyrs, her faith shown to be stronger than Bao’s.

Both Boxers and Saints are populated by secondary characters and situations that capture and hold our attention. Even during war, life has some funny moments. These include the dentist’s son who brings pulled teeth to use as toy soldiers when playing with young Bao and the Christian acupuncturist who ‘cures’ young Vibiana’s angry face by making her laugh. Some of the Boxers bawdily tease teenage warriors for thinking with their “turtle heads” whenever women are around. Then there is the unexpected tenderness shown by some fierce fighters, such as Boxer Mei-wen. This leader of the women’s Red Lantern brigade nurses injured Saints as well as Boxers. It is clear that for Yang, regardless of his work’s two-volume format, war has many more than “two faces.” And some of these are truly terrible.

There are villagers on both sides who, along with European soldiers, are more interested in loot and rape than religion or patriotism. But the worst violence comes from individuals who believe their cause is righteous. A full-page panel in Boxers, dominated by multiple, capital-lettered cries of “KILL!,” reflects the angry shouts of Boxers ready to attack Peking and conveys the horror that is to come. Bao commits a war crime comparable to any act attributed to Michael Karkoc. Reminding himself of the atrocities Christians supposedly commit, Bao sets fire to a locked church filled with women and children. All die horribly. Bao’s hesitation before this savage slaughter contrasts with how easily some European soldiers later kill any Chinese who they think is not Christian. Despite Gene Luen Yang and his publisher’s division of his story into two volumes, Boxers and Saints are both just as nuanced and complex about war-torn life as any of the three volumes of Resistance. Yang has said that he created these books so that they could stand along as separate works or be read in any order. While I agree that he has achieved this, I believe a reader would gain most by first reading Boxers and then moving on to Saints. Experienced together in this way, the duology is indeed more than the sum of its parts.

We are, sadly, still in the midst of learning and relearning history’s lessons about war-torn nations. The truths about Michael Karkoc’s actions in World War II Ukraine, an occupied country, are still being examined, with many people still insistent that there could only possibly be one truth in this matter. And in China just this past month, the Chinese government sent soldiers to the western province of Xinjiang to prevent Muslim Uighars, an ethnic minority group there, from observing the fast days of their holiest holiday, Ramadan. Thirty-five people were killed last month in this ongoing conflict. Perhaps it is time to turn to the latest headlines, choose just one of the many conflicts around the globe, and ask ourselves those awkward questions, “What would I have done?” “What will I do?”

Posted in graphic novels, war | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Stay Tuned

Although Natalie’s monthly column would normally be published on August 6th, she has written about Defiance: Resistance Book 2 by Carla Jablonski and Boxers & Saints by Gene Luen Yang. The latter will not be available until September 10th. At the publisher’s request, we are holding the review until August 20th, which is closer to the pub date. You’ll find Natalie’s new column right here, two weeks from now.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Captaining America: Tales of Two Icons

What could Captain America and Helen Keller possibly have in common?  Read on . . . .

As Independence Day approaches, movie theaters try to lure customers with patriotic blockbusters, or at least action-packed adventures, echoing the fight for freedom proclaimed on July 4, 1776. In recent years, these movie megahits have often featured the patriotic superheroes who first appeared in 1930s and 1940s comics. Yet their victories are not the only tales told about such icons as Captain America and Superman. Sometimes stories created about these fictional figures reveal our national flaws or failings. Similarly, we sometimes find out surprising truths about real-life heroes—little known incidents or events that deepen our understanding of these worthy people elevated over time into icons. Helen Keller, who triumphed over physical disabilities, is one of these iconic, real-life heroes.

This past month, two news items led me to recent graphic literature that tackles this issue of heroic fame vs. unvarnished truth—and does so in smart, entertaining, but also moving ways. An unexpected obituary for comic book writer Robert Morales (only 54 years old) reminded me of a version of Captain America that deserves to be much better known. Another news story described a letter, rescued from historical archives, that Helen Keller wrote, fiercely advocating free speech and religious tolerance. In her response to 1930s German book-burning, Keller in her own way captained American values. It is a bittersweet pleasure today, then, to highlight two exceptionally fine graphic works. One postulates the ‘hidden’ truth behind fictional Captain America, while the other examines some often overlooked truths in Helen Keller’s remarkable life story.

Truth: Red, White and BlackThe Captain America who first appeared in a 1941 Marvel comic book, created by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby, has undergone many transformations. At first, patriotic but frail Steve Rogers—given super strength and healing through an untested “super serum”—became  costumed Captain America and helped win World War II. Later, Marvel employees depicted blonde Rogers fighting in other wars, sometimes with a sidekick. Some storylines even had Rogers travelling back in time, entering alternate universes, becoming the president, or turning into a zombie! Yet it is a different origin story of Captain America, at first not meant to tie into the Marvel universe(s) of tales, that is my focus. In 2003, writer Robert Morales, with illustrator Kyle Baker, tackled racism in America in a seven issue “mini-series” about Captain America, collected under the title Truth: Red, White, and Black (2004). This trade paperback was reprinted in hardback as Captain America: Truth in 2009. 

Captain America: TruthMorales was surprised that Marvel Publications accepted his concept for its copyrighted superhero, since his Truth drew upon some “staggeringly depressing” history. Yet the project was championed by Marvel editor Axel Alonso, who found it “especially meaningful…” to “edit a story that functions as a little more than pure entertainment.” As each issue appeared, Alonso recalls, reviewers initially opposed to the series’ basic premise began to see that it was about “building bridges between people, not burning them…” That premise is apparent in the very first image of Captain America: Truth—an African American man in a Captain America costume! Over the course of the novel, we learn how this character, Isaiah Bradley, wears that suit with valor, even though he and other Black soldiers are treated shamefully by the U.S. government, enduring much more than the segregation of their era.

In Morales’ tale, before injecting Steve Rogers with its “super soldier” serum, the army first tests it on unsuspecting Black soldiers, many of whom suffer horribly and die during these unethical experiments. In his detailed Appendix to Captain America: Truth, Morales explains that he based this plot on the real-life exploitation of Black patients in the now infamous Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment. Hundreds were unethically left untreated in the name of science. This Appendix also gives the real-life history behind the many instances of racism depicted throughout the novel, which initially follows the lives of three Black men from different cities and social classes. Only the terrible injustice Isaiah Bradley experiences in the final chapters is extrapolated from the author’s imagination.

“Chapter One: The Future” introduces us to working class Bradley in New York, enjoying the 1939–1940 World’s Fair with his wife, Faith, who affectionately corrects his grammar as they sightsee. We next meet upper-class Maurice Canfield, greeted by his family’s butler in their Philadelphia mansion. Maurice’s words to his horrified mother about a violent confrontation with bigoted thugs reflect his educated, bitter wit. He says, “And one of them brought the meeting to a swift conclusion with a stream of invective—much of it about you, actually…” Luke “Black Cap” Evans is the novel’s third protagonist—a career soldier recently demoted from captain to sergeant for confronting a racist superior officer. “Cap” is playing pool in a Cleveland billiards parlor. One large panel there shows how well author Morales and illustrator Baker work together. As we see Cap about to sink a foregrounded white ball into a pool table pocket, Cap sarcastically notes, “This is the only place I get to shove ol’ whitey around.” Each character is linked to a different color palette, though Baker unites their stories—which come together after Pearl Harbor is attacked—with the same distinctive drawing style. With just a few, well-chosen exceptions, Baker conveys emotion and movement through the “comic-dynamic” style—non-realistic, cartoon-like drawing that uses flowing lines of different widths.

Isaiah Bradley is the sole survivor out of 300 Black soldiers who, in this origin story, give their lives so that Steve Rogers may become the Captain America.  Long before they succumb to brutal drug testing or battle, though, their families and friends are told they have died. A double-spread triptych, color-coded to each protagonist, depicts the premature grieving forced upon these families. Other powerful images in Captain America: Truth include scenes in which Isaiah Bradley, successfully fighting behind enemy lines, discovers the horrors of medical experimentation in Nazi death camps. Victims strapped to tables there eerily resemble the Black soldiers restrained by U.S. doctors as they developed the super soldier serum.

Each chapter also begins with an intense, full-page, red-white-and-black image or series of images linked thematically to its content. These are drawn with clear, bold lines—as though they were public murals or monuments carved in granite. “Chapter Three: The Passage” shows a black silhouette strapped down to a flag-striped, red and white medical gurney. A thin blue border surrounds this scene. “Chapter Five: The Math”—the combat chapter—begins with three striking pages: Bradley’s black and white silhouette racing towards a concentration camp shown in twilight blue; a close-up of his silhouetted head, striped with white concentration camp numbers, against a blood-red background; and that close-up repeated with the background now shown as a distorted American flag, red and white stripes blasted into psychedelic squiggles. That mind-blowing transformation, for me, sums up the overall impact of Morales and Baker’s hard-hitting, innovative novel.

Truth: Captain AmericaCaptain America: Truth, though, does not end on a downbeat note. In “Chapter Six, The Whitewash,” Isaiah Bradley is captured but resists the attempts of Nazi officials (including Hitler himself!) to win him to their side. And, when Steve Rogers later learns how Bradley’s valor was concealed and his bravery actually punished by the U.S. Army, Rogers sets out to correct this terrible whitewashing of the truth. In the final, seventh chapter, tellingly titled “The Blackvine,” Rogers and we readers learn that Isaiah Bradley—while permanently damaged by official U.S. injustice—had never been forgotten by his wife Faith. Bradley has also achieved word-of-mouth fame and respect in the Black community and its supporters. On a double page spread, we see a costumed Steve Rogers examining a wall of photographs of world-renowned celebrities posing with smiling Isaiah Bradley. These are drawn realistically for easy identification. Everyone from South African leader Nelson Mandela to boxer Mohammed Ali and film maker Spike Lee, it seems, has known the truth about the first Captain America long before Steve Rogers and us readers!  The book’s final narrative page shows a photo of both costumed Captain Americas, shoulder- to-shoulder and smiling. An inserted, smaller snapshot of joyful young Isaiah and Faith Bradley suggests that injured Isaiah is genuinely as happy now. He has made his own peace with the brutal “truths” just revealed to us so brilliantly by Robert Morales and Kyle Baker. Their tale suggests it is possible to move past our country’s shared hurtful past, once it is acknowledged.

Annie Sullivan: The Trials of Helen KellerThis “hidden” story of fictional Captain America is mirrored by the hidden (or at least overlooked) stories of real-life hero Helen Keller. Anyone who has seen William Gibson’s play The Miracle Worker, or the 1962 Oscar winning film version, might think a  book could not rival that portrayal of young, blind-deaf Helen first comprehending language. Yet Lambert’s Annie Sullivan and the Trials of Helen Keller (2012) depicts this stunning moment at least as well as Gibson does.

Helen Keller's pagesLambert conveys the “trial” of blind-deafness through color and line.  Before Helen understands language, Lambert casts her as a roughly outlined pale grey shadow against a black background. The touch of others is drawn as swooping, roughly outlined blue swatches. The finger signs Sullivan tries to teach Helen are also depicted in blue. Lambert creatively uses vertical and horizontal blue lines and swirls, separately and in combination, to show how Helen learns to connect water pouring out of a pump, her hand plunging into a pitcher of water, and falling droplets with the word “water.” As Helen acquires more language, filling the void that was her mind, Lambert fills the black background of panels with more and more labeled, outlined images of objects, in assorted muted hues.

Annie Sullivan's pagesIn contrast, the daily life of Annie Sullivan, Helen’s teacher, is depicted in a schematic style, devoid of shadows, both before she meets Helen and once Helen acquires language. This hyper-realistic style changes only when Lambert reveals their other “trials.” These centered upon Sullivan’s complex relationship with the Perkins School for the Blind in Boston, where vision-impaired Sullivan received her own education and where the Kellers found help for Helen. As Helen’s achievements receive public attention, Sullivan resents publicity that emphasizes Perkins School rather than her own efforts. This attitude leads to the book’s two other “trials.”

Lambert’s book shows how Sullivan wrongfully attempted to ignore historical fact: Helen Keller was not the first blind-deaf child successfully taught language at Perkins. Fifty years earlier, its founder had taught 8-year-old Laura Bridgman to communicate. Sullivan as a student at Perkins had even known Bridgman. Sullivan’s dismissive attitude influenced how Perkins staff handled the next “trial,” which actually bordered on a crime. The magazine which had published a fairy tale, “The Frost King,” supposedly written by 11-year-old Helen, discovered an almost identical story, titled “The Frost Fairies,” written by someone else and published earlier in a book. The magazine and Perkins officials accused Sullivan and Helen of plagiarism. Lambert uses multiple visual styles to depict the story itself, and again uses grey shadows against a black background to show how tired, confused, and anxious Helen became during the many hours she was questioned about this matter. Helen’s ability to remember long passages word-for-word clouded the issue, too. Finally, Helen and Sullivan are never officially charged and condemned for plagiarism, yet they leave Perkins under a cloud of doubt.

In his book’s appendix, detailing the facts behind its panels, Joseph Lambert does not take sides about this little-known controversy. His final storytelling images also let readers reach their own conclusions about the possible plagiarism. From one panel to the next, Helen and Annie Sullivan’s faces move from full-featured illustrations to shadowy outlines, just as Helen sometimes feels the sun’s warmth as she clings to Sullivan but sometimes feels chilled as a cloud literally covers the sun. This is a smart, moving way to show the affection and need that bind Helen Keller and Annie Sullivan together, regardless of any deliberate or accidental wrongdoing. Annie Sullivan and the Trials of Helen Keller richly deserves its recognition as a YALSA Best Graphic Novel (2013) and other accolades praising it for upper elementary and middle school readers, too.

This blog entry is now complete, but tales of these icons and others continue. I still have a library copy of Helen Keller in Love (2012) to read. I just happened to see this historical novel by Rosie Sutton on an entryway bookshelf the other week. There is also the latest Superman movie, Man of Steel, to ponder. I saw it in larger-than-life 3D at a local mall cinema yesterday. And there is Marvel’s latest alternate universe Spiderman to consider. In August, 2011, young Miles Morales, a teen of African American and Latino descent, stepped in for Peter Parker there. I have not read any of his adventures yet … perhaps you have, or perhaps you have another tale about icons to share here.

Posted in graphic novels | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Being Different: Artists and Other Outsiders

I am celebrating! Last month, the state of Minnesota legalized same-sex marriage, removing one layer of hurtful, official “difference” from our local landscape. As emotional and social landscapes continue to shift, too, we may see some changes in how graphic literature depicts same-sex relationships. Discovery or revelation of sexual identity might no longer typically be the plot’s “crisis”—gay adults, teens, and kids may have other, more crucial matters on their minds. And more gay characters may show up as secondary characters as an unexceptional part of everyday life. Yet other individuals with fluid gender identities and complex sexual feelings will continue to be “outsiders” in a world that typically still demands clear-cut, either-or categories. Today, I am highlighting graphic works whose main figures are artists, already set apart by their calling. Some of these characters are also outsiders because of their sexuality, others because their religion brands them as different and inferior. Engaging, satisfying, disturbing, moving—get ready for a roller-coaster of emotions as I tell you about these five excellent books.

Page by PaigeThe focal character in author/illustrator Laura Lee Gulledge’s Page by Paige (2011) is 16-year-old Paige Turner. (She thinks her punning name is too cute, too.) Her family’s recent move from Virginia to New York City has left Paige feeling lost and insecure. Trying to figure out what to do about this, the young artist realizes, “I know I need to draw about it.” Gulledge’s work is, in fact, structured as a month-by-month sketch book kept by Paige, with each section also subtitled with one of her grandmother’s adages about art and life. One is “Figure out what scares you and DO IT.” Paige also thinks and feels in images. So, when she imagines ridding herself of negative thoughts, we see Paige’s head shaped like an upside-down salt shaker, with all those negative “shoulds,” “perhaps,” and “maybes” literally being shaken right out of her head! When she feels heartened by a hug from her father, we see her sheltered in the center of a large, intertwined skein of many loving arms.

Whether depicting Paige acquiring friends and a boyfriend, negotiating new rules with her parents, or learning about city laws and neighborhood norms for public art, Gulledge gives readers a visually rich experience. This work’s black-and-white interior is filled with panels of assorted sizes and creative shapes, used in effective counterpoint to the storyline, and alternating with panel-free single and double page spreads. Wind-blown hair, waving arms, and emotion-filled word balloons are just some of the items that “spill over” to unite panels. Gulledge uses a variety of greys to suggest different moods and times of night, and adds “punch” to some scenes through the use of black backgrounds or silhouettes.  She also knows how to use wordless pages effectively—for instance, sometimes filling them with many small panels to convey time’s “dragging” as Paige waits for sleep or inspiration. Accepting the challenges and responsibilities of making art is one of Gulledge’s central themes here.

A shared love of comics and similar musical tastes bring Paige and her new high school friends together. An early, brief exchange about a lesbian comic book character establishes that female Jules is gay while Paige is straight. After a wordless panel in which the two smile at each other, this difference recedes into the background of their friendship. It surfaces again briefly only when musical Jules refers to a lesbian singer and Paige talks about her feelings for her boyfriend Gabe. Sexual orientation is just a footnote in their lives, as are the mixed ethnic identities of Jules, her brother Longo, and Gabe. In this joyful, up-to-the-moment graphic novel—referencing contemporary comics and musicians and filled with smart phone texts and photos, laptop Instant Messaging, and even its own playlist—Paige and Gabe’s relationship is sweetly old-fashioned. They kiss and bump knees under schoolroom desks, but when Gabe teasingly asks, “Want to step it up a notch?” we see what he means is holding hands! Paige’s reply, along with a close-up of her face, show that hand-holding is just the right level of physical intimacy for the pair. Gulledge’s emphasis on slowly–evolving, highly-prized emotional intimacy rings true in this novel of adolescence. I think it will also resonate with younger as well as older readers, too.

Page by Paige was honored as a nominee for both the 2012 Eisner Award and YALSA Teens’ Top Ten. It was a Booklist Great Graphic Novel Pick for 2012 as well. I believe that Gulledge’s just published Will & Whit (2013) will earn comparable kudos. Its 17-year-old protagonist, Wilhemina Huckstep, is a craft artist, specializing in hand-made lamps. She and her cohort of high school juniors—along with one 13-year-old kid sister—grow closer and learn more about themselves, each other, and their families when Hurricane Whitney (the title’s “Whit”) blasts through their small Virginia community. From its first chapter, “Sparks,” through the “Shadowboxing” they do when the lights go out, to the “Illumination” characters experience during the town carnival they hold despite the storm, this new book is also a visual treat. Gulledge again plays with panel shape, size, and permeability; she uses close-ups on faces and other body segments to great effect; and panel-free pages convey different kinds of energy and motion as characters lazily float along a stream or desperately seek shelter during a hurricane. The mysterious shadows that haunt Will right from the novel’s start are explained and satisfyingly dealt with in its last pages, too!

a+e 4everThe tone and look of author/illustrator I. Merey’s gripping a + e 4EVER is much different than Gulledge’s novels. Merey uses visual elements typical in Japanese manga to depict the sometimes bleak and painful experiences of her teenage protagonists. High school juniors Asher (“a” or Ash) and Eulalie (“e” or Eu) have the emotional needs typical of teens, but these young artists are unconventional in appearance and/or sexual orientation. Eu chooses to dramatize her spindly, 6 foot height with Goth clothing, a half-shaved head, and a bad attitude. Ash emphasizes his slight stature, girlish appearance and bisexuality with tight, sparkly clothing. Merey introduces Ash in scenes depicting his being bullied in the high school boys’ room, where readers wait along with the bullies to discover Ash’s biological gender. Eu is introduced when she rescues a surprisingly ungrateful, prickly Ash from lunchroom bullying. When the two finally do bond over their shared musical taste and interest in art, Eu asks taciturn Ash what drawing means to him. His one word reply, offset prominently in a different font, is “escape.” Brutal handling and parental indifference have left Ash unable to tolerate touch of any kind. This becomes Eu’s problem as well as Ash’s since—despite the general assumption that large, assertive Eu is a lesbian—she is heterosexual and falls in love with him. Ironically, Eu for much of the book is not “pretty” or sweet enough to merit any of Ash’s limited interest in having a “girlfriend.” 

Merey draws characters with the large eyes and small mouths typical in manga. Anger shown as an unrealistically fanged mouth, other strong emotions shown as tiny droplets of sweat, plus an overall emphasis on minimally-lined figures and blank, single-toned, or hatch-marked backgrounds are also typical of manga. Roughly-drawn, angular lettering that matches characters’ intense feelings is a further manga element. The occasional Japanese word such as “kira” for sparkly also reinforces this frame of reference, a favorite subgenre for teen and preteen readers. High school students will certainly empathize with the first love, school scenes, and retreat into music depicted here. That a teenage ‘forever’ might be thwarted by adult family plans will also painfully resonate for many young readers, whether or not they also see themselves in Ash and Eu’s differences or are just “reality surfing.” That is the term Laura Lee Gulledge’s teens use for “exploring scenes and subcultures” which are, as Paige puts it, “nice to visit, but not all of them are for me.”

Yet, just as some manga is more explicit and generally adult-oriented, readers will find that publication by small, independent Lethe Press has given Merey more latitude than mainstream publishers often extend to authors of YA literature. Her teenage characters realistically utter the occasional obscenity or profanity. There is in-context mention of masturbation. And Merey also depicts dangerous behavior and the results of poor choices. Ash, having taken a “feel-good” pill offered by a stranger in a music club, really cannot give informed consent for the sexual encounter that follows. We witness what he later denies is his being raped. The promiscuous homosexual behavior Ash then begins is part of this denial. When Ash and Eu finally have sex with one another, it is an affirmation of emotional intimacy and psychological healing for bisexual Ash. Their nude, seemingly androgynous bodies, sketched in expressionistic lines common in manga, are both plot and theme appropriate. Merey’s work travels a different, stonier path than Gulledge’s, but both graphic novelists emphasize the importance of emotional and cultural connections for their teen protagonists—and, by extension, their readers.

Writing about their own lives, two veteran illustrator/authors add historical dimension to points raised by Gulledge and Meray. Immigration is key to the powerful graphic works that award-winning Allen Say and Joe Kubert have created about artistic outsiders. Once again, these works differ from each other in outlook and tone.

Drawing from MemoryAn illustrator of Caldecott-winning picture books for young readers, Allan Say in his memoir Drawing from Memory (2011) shows as well as tells about his fierce desire to be an artist. As a boy in 1930s and 1940s Japan, he had to overcome his family’s disdain for this ambition. His father, Say recalls, even said, “I expect you to be a respectable citizen, not an artist …”  Kids will be fascinated by the determination with which young Say took every chance to seize his dream. Readers of all ages will be tickled to learn that teenaged Say and his fellow art apprentices actually appeared as characters in early manga comics penned by their sensei (master teacher), Norei Shinpei! Delightful panels from those strips, along with Say’s own softly-colored, more realistically styled drawings and black and white photographs illustrate this upbeat hybrid work, half-graphic novel and half-picture bookBeginning with his earliest years, it concludes with 17-year-old Say immigrating to the United States. A final, illustrated Author’s Note summarizes Say’s adult career and last meeting, in 2002, with his revered sensei. Their mutual respect and affection is touching. Drawing from Memory was commended as an Honor Book in the 2012 Robert F. Sibert Informational Book Award competition.

Yossel, April 19, 1943What might have happened to Allen Say, though, had he not immigrated? We may speculate, but we cannot know for sure. Jewish Joe Kubert, however, is certain that his family’s 1926 immigration from Poland, when he was an infant, saved his life. Unlike I. Meray’s Asher and Eulalie, who view their being Jewish as an almost irrelevant “difference,” by far the least of their concerns, in Poland Joe Kubert would almost surely have become a victim of the Nazi Holocaust. He would have been among the millions of people slaughtered just for being a Jew, along with millions of others declared criminally “different.” That alternate—and tragically truncated—lifetime, in a kind of alternate universe, is the basis of Kubert’s stunning graphic novel, Yossel: April 19, 1943: A Story of the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. (2003; 2011). Yossel is the Yiddish name usually translated as Joe. The book Yossel depicts the life Kubert imagines he would have led in Poland. Perhaps best known for his work on such comic book series as Sgt. Rock, Tarzan, and Hawkman, in the U.S. Kubert (1926-2012) began working as a cartoonist while still a young teen. He had earned a lifetime achievement award from the National Cartoonists Society and was inducted into the Comic Book Hall of Fame long before he began to write and illustrate graphic novels. Kubert depicts himself as young Yossel being similarly skilled with drawing and fascinated by comics. No superhero he draws, though, comes to rescue Yossel, his family, or neighbors. His ability to sketch portraits for Nazi officers and soldiers can only delay, not defeat death. As teenage Yossel listens to someone who has briefly escaped a concentration camp, his sketches capture and foreshadow this fate. Covering an entire page, one remarkable image has bare feet foregrounded, toes pointing towards the top of the page where gaunt figures in striped uniforms are about to shutter a pair of doors. We are viewing the inside of a crematorium oven from the impossible, nearly unbearable vantage point of a corpse! Soon, it will be incinerated ash.

In his introduction to Yossel: April 19, 1943 (the day on which the brave but doomed Ghetto uprising began), Kubert explains that he chose to omit the standard cartooning practice of inking over penciled-in drawings, then erasing those first, hastier lines. Kubert kept the “immediacy” of the pencil drawings here “to convey a sense that these drawings were in Yossel’s mind, even though he may never have had the opportunity to put them all to paper.” This suggestion is certainly communicated in the work’s last pages, in which we hear Yossel think, as soldiers search the Ghetto for any surviving fighters, that “It felt good to draw again, to shut out the rest of the world, to feed my mind and my heart with that which makes me complete. No noise. No wetness. No heat. No cold. No pain. Nothing. . . . M-Mama.” The final gut-wrenching image of this moving work is a full page picture of a tellingly blank page. Unlike I. Merey’s Asher, Yossel cannot escape his pain and live, too.

As I skim now through the pages of Yossel: April 19, 1943, my mind turns again to the legislative shift that inspired today’s blog entry. I think of the pink triangles (used by Nazis to identify and doom homosexuals), the red triangles (for political prisoners), the purple triangles (for Bible students and other religious dissidents)—all the symbols that along with Jews’ yellow stars marked “difference” as evil, fit only for destruction. I am so glad to live here and now, proud to contribute in some small way to our more welcoming and open-hearted Minnesota.

Posted in graphic novels | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Private Lives and Public Moments: Making Memories

“Go make some good memories for yourself,” my father used to say, giving his approval for a teenage outing. “Making memories” is still an expression some people use for being alive. Yet there can be gaps between living through experiences and remembering them accurately—or even fully understanding them years later. This is particularly true when childhood or teenage experiences overlap with newsworthy events. Such intersections of private lives with public moments are the inspiration for four recent, compelling graphic memoirs. Some of their creators acknowledge the difficulties involved in finding and telling “the truth” about their lives. Others seem less aware of this problem. Yet these memoirs—ranging across three continents and unusual as well as everyday events—provide rich reading in both words and images. They also remind us that a focus on childhood or teenage years does not mean that a book is only or mainly for kids or teens.

Silence of our FriendsThe Silence of Our Friends (2012), written by Mark Long and Jim Demanokos and illustrated by Nate Powell, is based on Long’s 1960s boyhood in Houston, Texas. Racist white people and institutions there often clashed with black individuals and groups seeking equal civil rights. A 1967 sit-down protest at Texas Southern University, the subsequent police riot, and the arrest of wrongly accused students, followed the next year by Dr. Martin Luther King’s assassination, had a powerful impact on young Mark. As an 8- or 9-year-old white boy, though, his understanding of these headline-making events was limited. This memoir moves among three viewpoints: Mark’s naïve impressions; those of his father, a TV news reporter committed to telling truths, despite opposition; and the experiences of Larry Thomas, a black community activist who with his young family broke conventions by becoming friends with the Longs. In the concluding Author’s Note to this memoir, Mark Long explains that some of its “details … have been changed for storytelling purposes.” The self-aware writer adds, “Creating a book like this one requires finding a balance between factual accuracy and emotional authenticity. What we have striven to create is a story that offers access to a particular moment in time ….” I believe that Long and his co-authors—through their skillful graphic storytelling—reach this goal, placing us on the scene in moving, dramatic ways. Even readers unfamiliar with this era and its conflicts will be drawn quickly into the memoir through its creators’ storytelling choices.

Emphasizing Mark’s naïve view through words and pictures conveys the daily, insidious impact of racism. We first meet and see him low to the ground, as he is playing “soldier” and trying to avoid his sister, who wants to join in. Artist Powell shows us Mark’s close-up view of this pestering sister’s feet. The kids’ bickering—including yells for “MOM” to judge the dispute—seems very real, as does the sweetly smart-aleck way Mark at first says grace at supper: “God’s neat, let’s eat!” Scenes such as these, as well as others bike-riding at twilight and walking to and from school, make it even more shocking the first time we hear Mark and others casually use the “N” word. Black baiting is a childhood game in the Longs’ new Houston neighborhood, with linked speech bubbles conveying its sing-song chant. Mark’s parents quickly let their children know that this language and game are unacceptable, but their views are not typical. Houston remains unofficially segregated. When the Thomas family comes to visit, Mark and his two sisters already know the hit song “Soul Man,” but they and the Thomas kids have never played outside their own race. The speed with which, after brief awkwardness, they all whoop and holler together, enjoying the summer night, highlights the next months’ painful events.

We see young CC Thomas, riding her bike, deliberately injured by a white hit-and-run driver. Later, when Larry Thomas is refused service by a white convenience store owner, we see in a series of wordless panels how Thomas’ pent-up frustrations lead him to slap his young son. A whole family drama is played out as we next see this loving father’s wordless apology—an unexpected soda pop purchased at a black-owned shop—accepted by the son he then hugs. These pictures are truly eloquent. The rare “cuss word” spoken by adults as public confrontations become nightly news is also telling. Mark’s father faces pressure to lie or at least be silent about what he has seen during the riot. The authors’ choice to use only black, white, and greys in this book’s pictures is particularly effective. The grainy grey images shown on the era’s TV sets counterpoint and comment on what the two central families experience. The TV screens themselves become characters in this memoir—characters that sometimes lie through edited or incomplete newscasts.

My Friend DahmerAuthor/illustrator Derf Backderf (pseudonym of John Backderf) also chose black and white for his provocative, gripping graphic novel My Friend Dahmer (2012). In the 1970s Backderf attended high school with Jeffrey Dahmer, the disturbed teenager who later became one of the United States’ most notorious serial killers. For this reason, even the title here is eye-catching! Backderf describes this book as a novel because he researched the story, interviewing many former classmates and teachers, reading related FBI and police files, and reviewing print and TV interviews with Dahmer and his family in ways Backderf did not in 2002. That year he published a much shorter version of this story—the incomplete version Backderf now calls “a straight memoir … culled entirely from [his] memory and from stories [his friends and he] … shared over the years.” This author is well-aware of memory’s possible flaws. The stark colors here suggest 1970s TV, newspapers, and school yearbooks, as well as the palette of 1930s through 50s horror movies. As Backderf draws rectangular-jawed Dahmer—and as the few snapshots of Dahmer included here suggest—the large, bulky teen somewhat resembled the Frankenstein monster of those films.

Backderf, in the Preface, urges readers to empathize with Dahmer up until he first committed murder—around their high school graduation. After that, Backderf writes, the isolated and disturbed teen lost any right to pity and empathy. Yet Backderf does a phenomenal job drawing readers into Dahmer’s tormented early years. Right away, after a full-page establishing panel showing Dahmer walking along a deserted suburban road, we are literally walking in Jeffrey Dahmer’s shoes. In these wordless panels, we see only these sneakers from Dahmer’s view, as he trudges along head-down. Only the “CRUNCH” of his footsteps breaks the silence. We are shocked when he encounters a road-killed cat—the first shock of many in this book, which depicts emotional distress rather than scenes of gore. The most physical violence Backderf shows are several wordless panels in which Dahmer, after catching a small fish, stabs his catch repeatedly, chopping it to bits. That is distressing, but so are the ways in which 1970s school officials, family, and neighbors fail to recognize and treat young Dahmer’s constant drinking and other bizarre behaviors. Backderf’s final panels of teenaged Dahmer’s home are shown at night, in the literal as well as emotional darkness that has started to consume him. They contrast with the earlier, full page panel that foregrounded a sign congratulating high school seniors at graduation, with a school bus driving off into the distance. Ironically, that sign and occasion signal the moments when Dahmer doomed himself—and his multiple victims. If readers (including adults concerned about how to discuss this award-winning book and its subject matter) want further insights into Backderf’s graphic storytelling, the publisher provides a useful teachers’ guide.

Marzi: a MemoirMarzi: A Memoir (2011) and Little White Duck: A Childhood in China (2012) are both excellent, satisfying reads and are similar in other ways, too. Each tells about the early life of its female writer in a Communist country, while each artist is either the author’s life partner or husband. Marzi’s author Marzena Sowa grew up in 1980s Poland, but now lives in France with her French partner, graphic artist Sylvain Savoia. Little White Duck’s author Na Liu immigrated from China in 1999 to work in the United States, where she met and now lives with her husband, artist Andres Vera Martinez. Each memoir—while including several extraordinary, history-making events—is most focused on what everyday life was like for young kids and their families under Communism. And each of these acclaimed, episodic books is accessible to a much broader range of readers than either its marketed audience or the age of its protagonists might suggest. Marzi was published as a book for adults, but the vivid, wryly insightful experiences of preschool through 10 year-old Marzi are, I believe, accessible and captivating for all ages. Similarly, while Little White Duck was published for kid readers, its content and presentation will also appeal to older ones, readers whose greater knowledge will add further resonance to the history there.

Play, family, school, church, and chores are prominent in Marzi. The apartment building Marzi lives in and her grandparents’ farms are the centers of her life. She does not understand how international politics have led to ongoing food shortages and the scarcity of products such as telephones. Marzena Sowa just experiences and later records in acute detail the endless lines and squabbles that result. Young Marzi knows she longs for American bubble gum, but does not understand why chewing modeling clay instead is such a very bad idea! We see and hear how much she misses and worries about her father during a union strike, but her fears are not those of adults anxious about the Soviet Union’s response to this Solidarity movement. Young Marzi also does not realize what the “smoke” coming from a damaged “factory” in 1986 Chernobyl really is, while Marzena Sowa and Sylvain Savoia effectively convey the radiation concerns of terrified adults then.

Savoia maintains a very conventional use of six equal-sized panels to every page, but the imaginative details and varied perspectives he draws still make this memoir a visual treat. For instance, when Marzi dreams of seeing France, her pupils each contain a tiny Eiffel Tower. When she mentions the nostril hair of adults, we see from preschooler eye-level a panel filled with four sets of hairy nostrils! And as young Marzi describes the vicious words of an adult, we are shown the silhouette of a woman whose tongue is shaped like a machine gun. Savoia also effectively shifts from close-ups to mid and long distance views, supporting and amplifying Marzena Sowa’s words. While I remain a bit skeptical about her introductory claim that her “flawless memory” will not let her “recast everything,” that her “memory recorded everything [her] eyes took in …,” I do think Sowa’s recollections in the 225-page book are both extensive and sharp. It is also perhaps not coincidental that the muted color palette of this graphic memoir—mainly browns and greys, with “pops” of oranges and reds—echoes the few, faded color photos in the double-page photo montage that ends the book. The graphic creators here are committed to presenting an authentic view of imaginative Marzena Sowa’s sometimes painful but also, in retrospect, sometimes funny childhood.

Little White DuckIn her Afterward to Little White Duck, Na Liu writes that the “China I grew up in is disappearing. The China my parents knew is almost gone.” She and her husband created this book to preserve these experiences for future generations. Little White Duck focuses most on its author’s early school years of 1976 through 1980. Whenever it describes the experiences of Na Liu’s parents, those more distant years are colored in one soft, single shade. Na Liu’s own childhood is more colorful, with techniques typical of different Chinese styles of painting—some featuring widespread landscapes, others having boldly-outlined figures—used in panels of varying sizes and arrangements. These pages alternate with single and double-spread pages without any panel borders, and at times—whenever Na Liu is reading or thinking about Chinese legends, for instance—mythological figures hover behind panels or even fly high above the landscape. This visual richness enhances the combination of family experience and Chinese history shared here.

Young Na Liu cries when she learns “Grandfather” has died, but it is not a family member her family mourns. Rather, it is the death of Communist Party leader Chairman Mao Tse Tsung (referred to respectfully as ‘Grandfather”) which closes schools and brings tears to crowds of people. She will not understand why until years later. Similarly, Na Liu has to learn first-hand why it is not a good idea to wear her best clothing—that jacket with its pretty, white velvet duck—to the poor village where her father’s family still lives. The lives of children there are more impoverished than hers in many ways. She is stunned by one of their typical, brutal games.

A recent event shows that Na Liu was right in thinking that her memoir records a past that is quickly vanishing. One of its chapters describes how she and her younger sister try (with comically disastrous results) to live up to the ideals of Lei Feng Day. March 5 is the day this Communist hero is honored each year. Artist Martinez reproduces many of the photos and posters used to illustrate the good deeds, models of Communist ideals, this young man supposedly performed. He was a Communist rock star to young Na Liu, her family, and schoolmates! Yet when new movies about Lei Feng opened in China in March, 2013, few people attended. In several cities, not one ticket was sold for the first day of screenings. Nowadays, in China and elsewhere, skeptics point out that many photos of Lei Feng’s Communist selflessness take place where no photographer would have been present. The underlying “truth” of this important part of Na Liu’s past, supposedly proven by photographs, was probably false—propaganda made up by Communist officials. Creating memoirs is indeed a tricky, fascinating business. Reading graphic ones is fun on so many different levels, too. Little White Duck, acclaimed as a Best Book for Children, also holds much of interest for older readers.

Posted in graphic novels | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Sharp Objects and Sharper Kids: Redefining Heroism

What does it take to be a hero? In comics, physical daring and superpowers are typically needed. Spiderman broke new ground in the 1960s when teen Peter Parker realized that “with great power there must also come great responsibility.” Parker had to learn how to be an adult as well as a superhero. Now, I am happy to say, we have some great graphic novels recasting this lesson in purely human terms, with young women learning what it takes to be heroic adults. These are enormously entertaining reads, too.

In separate, fast-paced and fun series, a 10th grader and an eleven-year-old discover that a sharp blade, however skillfully wielded or magical, is not the solution to their problems. While trouncing trolls—and, later, bouncing meteors—these young heroes learn more about themselves and their own, everyday lives. That is the knowledge they need to rescue others and themselves. Meanwhile, we have a blast watching their fantastic adventures!

FoiledAliera Carstairs does not fit in at her New York City high school. In Foiled (2010) and its sequel Curses! Foiled Again (2013), we see how important the sport of fencing is to her. Through hours of hard practice, she may have the chance to compete nationally. If only the practice fencing foil her mother bought at a garage sale were not an enchanted one, revealing that Aliera is the destined Defender of Faerie. If only the handsomest guy in school, her lab partner Avery, were not really a troll. When things and people are not as they seem, what’s a 10th grader to do? What rules should be broken … what promises kept? Aliera’s cousin Caroline, wheel-chair bound with rheumatoid arthritis, is a major character in both books, helping Aliera with strategy.

Writer Jane Yolen and illustrator Mike Cavallaro are a dynamic duo in these books, creating plot, characters, and setting with a seamless mesh of words and images. Yolen plays with language as nimbly as one would expect from this acclaimed, veteran author, known as the “Hans Christian Andersen” of the United States. From witty remarks about “Every verbal thrust … parried,” chapter titles aptly named after fencing moves, and high school banter ranging from monosyllables to casual references to Shrek, Harry Potter, and The Wizard of Oz, not one note rings false. And the pacing is great. One example of how this writing team expertly blends words and pictures is a page in Curses! featuring trolls. After troll silhouettes atop the page tell Aliera that they intend to swat her flat, a mid-page series of five close-ups has each troll individually add: “Flat as a hat.” “Flat as a flounder.” “Flat as a board.” “Flat as a pancake.” “What’s a pancake?” At the bottom of the page, as the trolls march off with prisoner Aliera, an explanation of pancakes follows, with Aliera thinking she is pretty lucky the trolls are this easily distracted.

Curses! Foiled AgainThis variety of panel sizes, shapes, and perspectives is just one instance of Mike Cavallaro’s versatility and flair. The books’ action is also kept brisk with full page and double page spreads, and with pages where the absence of all words heightens tension and suspense. There is smart use of color to distinguish between the everyday world and Fairie, and to show Aliera’s growing ability to see the Fairie creatures infiltrating New York City. Sometimes Cavallero also uses different drawing styles to indicate velocity as creatures zoom, a magical storm rages, or Aliera charges into battle. I can see why Foiled was acclaimed as a YALSA Great Graphic Novel, A Texas Maverick Graphic Novel, and an Amelia Bloomer Recommended Title. I expect Curses! Foiled Again may win awards, too. I wonder if this second book contains the same clue that the first one did—a t-shirt Aliera wears there displays a quotation that became the next title. I think that careful readers may be able to spot and figure out the title of Aliera, Avery, and Caroline’s third, yet-to-be-written adventure.

Hereville: How Mirka Got Her SwordAuthor/illustrator Barry Deutsch identifies his hero and her adventures in his books’ titles:  Hereville: How Mirka Got Her Sword (2010) and its sequel, Hereville: How Mirka Met a Meteorite (2012). Deutsch also humorously tells readers a bit about Mirka’s everyday world with an additional line atop each book’s cover. “Yet Another Troll-Fighting Eleven-Year-Old Orthodox Jewish Girl” proclaims the first, while the sequel announces that Mirka is now “Boldly Going Where No Eleven-Year-Old Orthodox Jewish Girl Has Gone Before.” Hereville, as we soon see, represents those rare Jewish communities—such as those in Monsey, New York, and Lakewood Township, New Jersey—where strict religious observance governs all aspects of life. Such Chasidic Jews choose to live apart from the rest of society. Deutsch’s sensitive, even-handed, and wonderfully entertaining depiction of Chasidic Mirka’s first adventure won the 2011 Sydney Taylor Book Award for older readers. It was nominated for the Eisner, Harvey, and Nebula awards, too.

Mirka is a bit of a rebel, hiding forbidden books about monsters under her bed and unhappy about having to learn the “womanly” skill of knitting. How will she balance her genuine faith, the demands of a large family, and school rules and routines with her desire to “slay dragons”? When Mirka meets an unknown creature that she only thinks is a monster, she asks herself, “Am I hero or NOT?”  Rising to that supposed challenge, Mirka gets her magical sword. Yet, to defeat a troll, Mirka finds that sharp thinking and life lessons are much better weapons. You may be as surprised as that troll to see what actually proves to be his undoing! Throughout this book and its sequel, author Deutsch does a fine job capturing the verbal give-and-take of brothers and sisters, the jeers of school bullies, the gentle sarcasm of no-nonsense parents, and the harsher jibes of supernatural creatures. Whenever Mirka and her companions in typical Chasidic fashion use a Yiddish word or expression as part of their speech, these words are asterisked. A brief translation appears at the bottom of the page.

Deutsch’s illustrations sparkle with wit and variety. An amazed Mirka is shown in a two-part panel shaped like an exclamation mark! She is looking off to her right, at an elongated panel containing a tall old mansion. That panel’s top extends upward and inward, to form the peaked roof of the narrow house. Many times, characters’ heads or feet overlap into nearby panels, enhancing the intense emotional connection between scenes. Mirka’s braids whip across panels as she is fighting that first “monster,” and double-page spreads without any panel enclosures capture the furious energy and activity of Mirka’s encounter with the troll. When her younger brother Zindel worriedly follows Mirka, we see him peering around a panel and then pacing around an entire page.   Sometimes panels overlap or proliferate to suggest actions occurring in rapid succession.  In this book where the difference between day and night becomes an important plot element, Deutsch uses different colors for each. Mirka’s dawn triumph is revealed in a combination of soft daytime orange and fading nighttime blue.

Hereville: How Mirka Met a MeteoriteIn Mirka Meets a Meteorite, green enters Deutsch’s palette, as both Earth and then Mirka are threatened by the space rock that, due to her latest dealings with the troll, has crashed to Earth.  Mirka’s amazing race to reach a powerful, helpful witch before this crash occurs is shown in vivid detail, with her large, running figure overlaying many small thought panels. We then see close-ups of Mirka’s anguished face as she struggles to find strength, interspersed with close-ups of other body parts as she tries to rise from her knees or raise a foot just one more time. We turn the page right after seeing Mirka collapse only to see a wordless, double-page spread of the large blue meterorite just above the treetops! The next two pages keep us in further suspense, with images of blinding light, glimpses of a dazed Mirka, and the only words her bewildered, “What happened?” The fantastic answer to this question fuels the rest of the plot.

In this charming novel, a frustrated, very hungry Mirka comes to realize the importance of family togetherness and family history. Being the very best Mirka she can be turns out to be more important than any test of strength or knowledge  And her stepsister Rochel’s sharp wit turns out to be a more effective weapon than Mirka’s sword. You will have to read this fantasy novel to its very end, though, to find out which everyday skill Mirka uses to cushion her own crash landing on Earth.  I do not want to spoil that laugh-filled surprise.

Posted in graphic novels | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment